Occasionally I’ll read something that will just make me pause and say “WTF, over”. Today was one of those days, thanks to Linda Robinson and her weak Congressional testimony.
The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly
Special Operations is the new conventional force in the 21st Century. The entire DOD organization has shifted towards a Special Operations centric model.
This brings both good, bad and ugly to US SOCOM.
- The Good: increased funding and special programs.
- The Bad: political piggy backing on the community and installing “oversight” committees that put too much weight on the branches of the Spec Ops decision tree.
- The Ugly: ugly career politicians jockeying for power
Washington’s Special Operations power grab is no surprise to me. The ugly career politicians are jockeying for power and influence over SOCOM. It’s what career politicians do. They trade favors to stay in power (when they’re not voting themselves another raise). They do this by exerting control over process and funding.
Death by Political Committee
Enter Linda Robinson, a self-proclaimed expert on the Special Operations community. In her testimony before the House Committee on Armed Services Subcommittee on Emerging Threats and Capabilities, Linda Robinson details how U.S. Special Operations Forces can be restructured to better confront emerging challenges.
I have nothing against Linda. She’s obviously very intelligent, not a very good writer (I can’t stand people who use “look at me” vocabulary words) and not on solid ground opining about the Special Operations community.
This is my personal opinion, you decide for yourself.
I don’t care how many hours you stand alongside a doctor in the operating room, it doesn’t make you a doctor and comes nowhere near experiencing what it’s like to hold life and death and the responsibility of it all in your own hands. Sorry Linda, and shame on whoever brought you in to testify before the herd of lambs.
In her testimony, Linda Robinson says:
[pullquote_right]Is she serious? The fact she says this openly is pretty revealing with regards to her own confidence in presenting her non-expert suggestions on how to restructure Special Operations” – Brandon[/pullquote_right]
“You have my full bio, but I would like to note that I have spent 27 years reporting on and researching conflicts, and in the past 13 years my research has included a great deal of time in the field and at headquarters with special operations forces at all echelons…”
“…Chairman Thornberry, Ranking Member Langevin, and members of the subcommittee, thank you for the opportunity to appear before this distinguished panel. The purpose of my testimony is to provide thoughts on the future of U.S. Special Operations Forces to include recent initiatives being considered by U.S. Special Operations Command and the Department of Defense.
[pullquote_right]“We can’t conduct the hit sir, that’s not in our standard procedure manual“… – Brandon[/pullquote_right]
One is a policy issue: I believe that an established standard procedure for systematically weighing the costs and benefits of employing unilateral raids or strikes via unmanned drones could improve viability of….” – Linda Robinson
What Does The Future Hold For U.S. Special Operations?
Decision by committee. You’re witnessing the death of a thousand cuts by lamb politicians trying to grab onto the straps of the Special Operations community. We call them “strap hangers” where I come from.
Let it continue to happen and we will ultimately leave our Special Operations community without teeth. I’m not arguing that their shouldn’t be oversight and accountability for the community, there is an existing chain of command. What I’m saying is that whoever called this lady before the House of Representatives to give her weak ass testimony has a self-serving agenda. There are problems when you don’t let experts do their jobs, especially when it comes to lambs trying to lead lions.
I’m in the process of writing a series for SOFREP that covers the shift towards a US Special Operations Defense model, and how it’s affected Washington and the usual suspects. I will also share my thoughts on what I think we need to do to ensure that we don’t take the “Special” out of Spec Operations.
This is important because the more rules we put into the Warfighter’s ruck, the heavier and less focused he/she becomes. This makes it easier for our enemies to use our own rules against us.
We are fighting an enemy and evil ideology that has no borders and no committee oversight.
Time to start getting real people. Thanks for taking a look.
linwood Recon6 Copy that bro...be on the lookout for Arctic Warrior and Matt 2.0, Major Rod as just a few of the Warriors on this site, should preface that with some of the 'older' service members, lol There are just too many to name, but you get the idea, REP has a multitude of knowledgeable ppl on various subject and I know you will enjoy your time here, but it is addictive! Best...6
Recon6 linwood What's most encouraging is what the young guys have done and are doing...and I include this site in that. We'd just sit around the team room and bitch...so do the guys here, but constructively, and with a purpose. There're a LOT of 25 year olds now who've the trade- and field-craft it took some of us 20 years to learn...and they ain't afraid to use it in their nation's defense. That warms the old cockles.
linwood Recon6 Glad you made your journey here!! Rec'd on the "almost", you'll find a couple of us old Grunts that wish we could return to action, heart's willing, body says fuck no, lol....6
Recon6 linwood Thanks, my brother...recently found this site, linked through a news site I visit on occasion. VERY impressed, both with the focus and the reportage. Rubbing elbows with, and reading the opinions of, other people who know that wet, tired, hungry and horny do not constitute a game-stopper almost makes one feel young again...almost.... ...besides, as SOF folks, we're always learning...even if we're long past leaping into action....
linwood Damn, that was a way 'cool' post, lol impressed, first time I've seen you here, welcome....6