The Bolduc Brief: The Dangers of Foreign Military Presence in America – A Contradiction of MAGA Principles

Allowing foreign troops, such as those from Qatar, to be based in the United States contradicts several key principles associated with the “Make America Great Again” (MAGA) movement. Among these principles, the most directly violated is national sovereignty.

Violation of National Sovereignty

1. Sovereignty and Independence:

One of the central tenets of the MAGA movement is a strong emphasis on American sovereignty and independence from foreign influence. The presence of foreign troops on U.S. soil could be seen as undermining this principle by introducing external military forces into domestic affairs. It raises concerns about the control of U.S. territory and security operations, which runs counter to the MAGA commitment to prioritize the nation’s autonomy.

2. America First Doctrine:

The “America First” ideology promotes the idea that U.S. interests should come before international obligations or alliances. Allowing Qatari military personnel to operate within the U.S. can be viewed as a deviation from this principle, suggesting a prioritization of foreign partnerships over the direct interests and security of American citizens.

3. Public Safety and Security:

MAGA principles often stress the importance of ensuring national security and public safety. The introduction of foreign military personnel can spark concerns over national security, create vulnerabilities, and potentially distract from addressing internal challenges. This contradicts the MAGA focus on protecting American interests and citizens.

4. Limited Government and Local Control:

The MAGA movement promotes a vision of limited federal government intervention and increased local control. The presence of foreign troops can be seen as a federal decision that impacts local communities and bases, potentially diluting local governance and control over military matters.

Conclusion

In summary, allowing foreign troops such as those from Qatar to be based in the United States undermines key MAGA principles by challenging America’s sovereignty, compromising the “America First” doctrine, raising security concerns, and detracting from local control. Each of these considerations aligns closely with the foundational values of the MAGA movement and raises significant questions about the appropriateness of such an arrangement from both a policy and a philosophical standpoint.

Donald C. Bolduc