As the war in Ukraine enters its 9th month the news(SOFREP among them) has covered the weapons systems going to Ukraine in considerable detail. In the process we’ve learned a few things.
- The Ukrainians are not like the Afghans or the Iraqis. Put US weaponry in their hands and they will make good use of it. They are proving to be very capable students of new weapons and tactics. We are not wasting the good stuff on them. They are also pretty smart about improvising weapons they need and can’t get. For example, the lack of fighter planes and attack aircraft, and precision-guided munitions saw Ukraine improving a drone fleet that could function as a tactical air force and precision-guided artillery at the same time. Their ability to drop a hand grenade on a single soldier in a foxhole saves hundreds of rounds of ammunition that the Russians expend in rocket and cannon barrages.
- Some of the weapons we are replacing as obsolete are actually pretty current given that the Russians can no longer be reasonably called a “Peer Adversary” any longer. The Russians seemed to have pulled the wool over the eyes of most of the world’s military “experts” who believed that the Russians had the weapons they claimed to have, that they worked the way they claimed and that their troops were trained to razor edge proficiency. None of that was true. For the first several months, the Russian army was fighting a Ukrainian army trying to get its pants on and Russia was stopped cold. Not by the latest US and NATO weaponry but by old Russian equipment that the Ukrainians were using.
- Troop quality counts as much as weapons. When this war is over and the analysts start picking this thing apart, an inescapable fact will be staring them right in the face: The Ukrainian soldier is just of better quality, education, and motivation than the Russian soldier. Russia began the war with a vastly superior force(Not enough to take Ukraine in our considered opinion) in tanks, guns, planes, and resources and saw it all melt right before their eyes because the quality, training, and motivation of their troops was just plain awful. Desertion in Russin ranks seemed to have begun in the first days of the war and just keeping their men from quitting or just surrendering in mass to Ukraine is one of the biggest challenges faced by Moscow.
After nine months of war, the average Russian combat soldier has gotten pretty good at soldiering. He has by now been in numerous firefights, had rounds whizzing by his head, and taken some measure of the fighting abilities of his enemy. The Ukrainian is fighting for the survival of his country, its culture, its history, its language, and its future. He fighting to preserve something for himself and his family.
By contrast, the average Russian soldier is a hastily called-up trainee, lacking experience, equipment, as well as career NCOs and officers to lead him into battle. He is fed 3 times a week, his weapon is often worn out or a relic from WWII. He is being told to fight to destroy the supposed “Nazis” in Ukraine which threaten Russia’s existence simply by existing themselves. He comes from a town without paved roads, reliable electricity, running water or indoor plumbing and arrives in Ukraine as see asphalt roads leading to homes with plumbing, electricity, and most of the trappings of first-world countries. He wonders how bad the Nazis can really be if they are living this well and wonders what the Nazis would want to “take” from Russia when they seem to have everything they need already. He doesn’t really want to be there.
The point here is to say that the value of the Ukrainian soldier at this point in the war is actually very high. They are veteran fighters now and can train new recruits that come into their units to help them stay alive as well. Every loss is not just personal but also the loss of training and experience as well. Since green Russian troops tend not to survive their first or second battle with Ukrainian troops, they can’t get better. This is reflected in the inability of the Russian army to do anything but lose ground to Ukraine since they launched their counter-offensive in August. Russia keeps throwing green recruits into the fight and they keep losing ground.