The reasons behind the decision to destroy all F-14 Tomcats

There was only one foreign customer for the advanced F-14 Tomcat fighter during its heyday: Iran. The Shah chose to buy 80 Tomcats instead of the F-15 Eagle — and they proved a good investment. Even after Imperial Iran gave way to the Islamic Republic of Iran after the 1979 revolution, the Iranian Air Force was still stacked with some of the best Tomcat pilots in the world.

And the U.S. doesn’t want any of them in the air again ever.

Iran is the United States’ ex-girlfriend that we just can’t stop thinking about. After the Islamic Revolution, the U.S. could just not leave Iran alone. A major sticking point for the United States was that our ex still had 30 of our best fighter aircraft, and they were using it to great effect against our new boo, Iraq, in the Iran-Iraq War. The Iranian Air Force was so skilled that in the Iran-Iraq War that a lone F-14 Tomcat could clear the skies of enemy aircraft without firing a shot. Many of the downings of Tomcats were at the hands of ground-based SAM batteries… Iranian SAM batteries.

But the United States eventually gets better stuff, no matter how iconic “Top Gun” is. Since the Tomcat, we’ve had the major advances in fighter technology — technology so amazing it might seem like magic to some. Those advances led us to develop the F-22 and F-35 fighters. So it made sense to retire our fleet of F-14s in 2007, given that we had an air superiority fighter that had the radar cross-section of a bumblebee and could take out enemy planes before it could physically see them. When Iran got wind of its retirement, you could practically hear the CEO of Northrop Grumman’s tummy growling at the idea of parts’ sales.

But nope. This was 2007 and Iran was still firmly placed in President George W. Bush’s “Axis of Evil,” along with North Korea. The idea of selling Iran rare F-14 parts, so it wouldn’t have to cannibalize its own F-14 inventory, was preposterous. It was this concern that led the Pentagon to shred every last leftover F-14 Tomcat.

Did the United States have to take a $38 million plane and reduce it to scrap metal just so Iran couldn’t repair its aging fleet? No, according to many national security experts, it did not. The move was more symbolic than practical. F-14 parts were considered sensitive equipment just for this reason. The U.S. ended all parts sales to anyone, not just Iran, for fear that Iran might get them eventually. But that doesn’t matter: there isn’t much Iran could do now with its F-14s even if they were airworthy.

“Those planes as they age are maybe the equivalent of Chevrolets in Cuba. They become relics of a past era,” said Larry C. Johnson, a former deputy chief of counterterrorism at the State Department in President George H.W. Bush’s administration. “Even if they can put them in the air, they are going to face more advanced weapons systems.”

The decision to destroy all the surplus Tomcats was the defense equivalent of taking the house and the car despite not needing or wanting either — a purely spiteful move that makes Tomcat fans wish they would have just donated to museums.

And the U.S. doesn’t want any of them in the air again ever.

This article was written by Blake Stilwell and originally published on We Are The Mighty.