In modern military operations, the role of Generals and Admirals is critical in shaping the direction and outcomes of defense strategies. However, there has been an increasing concern over the failure of these top-ranking officers to fulfill their duties effectively. This essay examines the reasons behind this perceived failure and the implications for our military today.
I am a retired General Officer, and I know these mistakes. I have taken responsibility for these failures and my shortcomings. Accountability, commitment, trust, and the truth have been marginalized in the military. It is time to change and restore the values and principles needed to ensure our military can do its job for the American people.
One of the primary reasons for the failure of Generals and Admirals is the disconnection between strategy and implementation. The military’s senior leadership seems to be concerned with their continued advancement, stuck at the tactical level, focused on conventional warfare mindsets, concerned with pleasing their political masters, and failing to adjust to the changing dynamics of modern warfare. This mindset and approach have caused a lack of innovative strategies, a critical factor in today’s rapidly evolving battlefield.
Moreover, the prevailing culture of bureaucracy and political correctness often stifles candid discussions about critical issues. Generals and Admirals are constantly walking on eggshells to avoid political backlash, and they fail to address problems inherent within the system because they fear repercussions. This culture has led to the suppression of innovative ideas and the promotion of ‘yes men’ who are not critical thinkers. This failure to encourage open dialogue, contrarianism, and constructive criticism has, in turn, affected the military’s operational efficiency. An example is the decisions made and sustained in dealing with COVID-19 in the military devastated service members. These decisions have still not been corrected, and many service members and their families still suffer. Generals and Admirals have failed to prevent wokeness from undermining readiness in the military. Wokeness in the military is being imposed by elected and appointed leaders in the White House, Congress, and the Pentagon who have little understanding of the purpose, character, traditions, and requirements of the institution they are trying to change.
The disconnect between the top-ranking officers and the ground troops is another concerning factor. Generals and Admirals are often accused of making decisions from the comfort of their offices without fully understanding the realities of the field. This lack of firsthand experience and understanding can lead to flawed strategies, potentially endangering the lives of servicemen and women. The failure of Generals and Colonels to listen to the ground commander in Niger resulted in an ambush that unnecessarily killed US Special Forces and Niger soldiers.
Recruiting and retention are two critical areas that determine the strength and readiness of a military force. The climate that Generals and Admirals have developed has negatively impacted both. When moms and dads feel political and military leadership cannot be trusted, they are less likely to promote the military as an option for their children. In addition, the retention rate is negatively impacted by poor senior military leadership that micromanages, fails to provide cover, and fails to trust their subordinates. A proposal to reduce Army Special Operations Forces due to failed recruitment is an example of the poor strategic critical thinking by senior leaders.
Furthermore, there is a perceived failure to maintain proper military ethics and standards. Several incidents have spotlighted the lack of accountability and moral integrity within the senior ranks (Afghanistan withdrawal, COVID policies, woke policies, poor readiness, Ukraine policy, Taiwan policy, and poor resource management). These incidents have eroded the trust and respect of those serving under them and the public, undermining the overall morale and effectiveness of the military.
To ensure the military’s effectiveness and efficiency in the face of evolving global threats, several areas require urgent attention and improvement.
Firstly, the military must foster a culture of innovation and adaptability. The nature of warfare is continuously changing, and the military needs to develop strategies that align with these changes. This requires a shift away from traditional warfare mindsets towards more flexible and innovative approaches that incorporate advancements in technology and take into consideration the changing geopolitical landscape.
Secondly, there needs to be an improvement in communication and connection between the senior leadership and the ground troops. The realities of the battlefield should inform decisions and strategies made by Generals and Admirals. This means that Generals and Admirals need to maintain open lines of communication with soldiers on the ground to understand their challenges, needs, and insights better.
Thirdly, ethical standards within the military need to be reinforced. A culture of accountability and integrity should be promoted at all levels, particularly among the top-ranking officers. Any lapses in ethical conduct should be addressed swiftly and transparently regardless of rank to restore trust and respect within the ranks and with the public.
Fourthly, the military should improve resource management. Resources should be allocated efficiently, ensuring necessary funds go towards essential areas such as personnel training, equipment maintenance, and soldier welfare. Checks and balances should be put in place to prevent wastage and corruption.
The military should work towards eliminating bureaucracy and promoting a culture of open dialogue. Constructive criticism should be encouraged, and the ‘yes men’ culture should be discouraged. This will foster critical thinking and problem-solving, which are crucial for the success of military operations.
In conclusion, the failure of Generals and Admirals in today’s military is a complex issue encompassing various facets, from a lack of innovative strategies to a failure to maintain ethical standards. To address these failures, a radical shift is needed in the military leadership culture, how senior leaders are selected, and accountability. This shift must encourage open dialogue, foster innovative thinking, establish stronger connections with ground troops, and enforce stringent accountability measures; leadership, especially among Generals and Admirals, has significant implications on the effectiveness and reputation of the military. These failures have threatened national security, demoralize the troops, and erode public trust in the military. Furthermore, they have led to a waste of resources, both human and financial, and potentially endanger the lives of servicemen and women. Therefore, it is imperative to address these issues promptly and effectively to ensure the military’s readiness and effectiveness in defending the nation.
Donald C. Bolduc
COMMENTS
There are
You must become a subscriber or login to view or post comments on this article.