Soldiers in the trenches, Gallipoli, 1915. (Ernest Brooks, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons)
World War I happened more than 100 years ago. With that amount of time, the details of what and what did not happen during that long but not forgotten time had merged into a mush of facts and myths passed down from one generation to another, especially now that books were not the only source of information for people. Here are some of the commonly told myths of the First World War that have been debunked by historians.
The Number One Killer of WWI Was the Machine Gun
Whenever we picture World War I, perhaps the very image we have in our minds is of men in dirty uniforms running into no man’s land as they scream at the top of their lungs while waving their machine guns. Although it was quite a dramatic and powerful scene, the reality was that the weapon responsible for causing the largest number of deaths during WWI was the artillery weapons. Safe to say that it was an artillery war.
In Stephen Bull’s book titled Trench: A History of Trench Warfare on the Western Front (2010), he concluded that the biggest killer on the western front was the artillery, responsible for “two-thirds of all deaths and injuries.” Out of the two-thirds, a third of them resulted in death, while the remaining two-thirds suffered from injuries, so they were either entirely obliterated, dismembered, or shell shocked. Between 1915 and 1918, seven out of ten British casualties were caused by artillery. The statistics were the same as the number of casualties for the French army.
Soldiers Were in the Trenches All Year Long
The situation in the trenches was far from ideal: There were plenty of rats, no proper human waste and garbage disposal, it stank, and filthy mud flooded the trenches during the rainy season. One could only imagine how horrible and difficult it was for the soldiers to have to endure the situation to fight for the nation and to think that the war lasted for several years!
While the awful living situations were definitely true, they did not stay and live in the trenches for the whole duration of the war. On average, soldiers stayed for four days at a time in the trenches before they were sent away. Imagine how it would crush the morale and the health of the troops if they had to stay in a God-forsaken place for an extended period of time. The British Army, for instance, would rotate their men in and out of the trenches, so a soldier would only have to stay for around ten days per month in the trenches. Sometimes, the soldiers would be away from the trench lines a whole month before they were called to return.
Women Were Not Allowed to Fight
When World War I began, the rules of most militaries were pretty strict about not allowing women to join in the active fighting. While it was true that Britain and America did not permit women in combatant roles, there were those who sneaked in and pretended to be men like Dorothy Lawrence.
In other countries like Russia, Romania, Bulgaria, and Serbia, women were allowed to serve as combat troops. In Russia, a woman named Maria Bochkareva founded the “Women’s Battalion of Death.” She was the first woman ever to lead a Russian military unit. However, she had to go through wiring a petition to the Czar to enlist in the Imperial Russian army and endure harassment and ostracization. In the end, she became a decorated soldier.
Further, all-women units were created in 1917, like the 1st Petrograd Women’s Battalion, which was utilized to defend the Winter Palace. Bochkavera’s unit was also present in the October Revolution, fighting at the front.
World War I happened more than 100 years ago. With that amount of time, the details of what and what did not happen during that long but not forgotten time had merged into a mush of facts and myths passed down from one generation to another, especially now that books were not the only source of information for people. Here are some of the commonly told myths of the First World War that have been debunked by historians.
The Number One Killer of WWI Was the Machine Gun
Whenever we picture World War I, perhaps the very image we have in our minds is of men in dirty uniforms running into no man’s land as they scream at the top of their lungs while waving their machine guns. Although it was quite a dramatic and powerful scene, the reality was that the weapon responsible for causing the largest number of deaths during WWI was the artillery weapons. Safe to say that it was an artillery war.
In Stephen Bull’s book titled Trench: A History of Trench Warfare on the Western Front (2010), he concluded that the biggest killer on the western front was the artillery, responsible for “two-thirds of all deaths and injuries.” Out of the two-thirds, a third of them resulted in death, while the remaining two-thirds suffered from injuries, so they were either entirely obliterated, dismembered, or shell shocked. Between 1915 and 1918, seven out of ten British casualties were caused by artillery. The statistics were the same as the number of casualties for the French army.
Soldiers Were in the Trenches All Year Long
The situation in the trenches was far from ideal: There were plenty of rats, no proper human waste and garbage disposal, it stank, and filthy mud flooded the trenches during the rainy season. One could only imagine how horrible and difficult it was for the soldiers to have to endure the situation to fight for the nation and to think that the war lasted for several years!
While the awful living situations were definitely true, they did not stay and live in the trenches for the whole duration of the war. On average, soldiers stayed for four days at a time in the trenches before they were sent away. Imagine how it would crush the morale and the health of the troops if they had to stay in a God-forsaken place for an extended period of time. The British Army, for instance, would rotate their men in and out of the trenches, so a soldier would only have to stay for around ten days per month in the trenches. Sometimes, the soldiers would be away from the trench lines a whole month before they were called to return.
Women Were Not Allowed to Fight
When World War I began, the rules of most militaries were pretty strict about not allowing women to join in the active fighting. While it was true that Britain and America did not permit women in combatant roles, there were those who sneaked in and pretended to be men like Dorothy Lawrence.
In other countries like Russia, Romania, Bulgaria, and Serbia, women were allowed to serve as combat troops. In Russia, a woman named Maria Bochkareva founded the “Women’s Battalion of Death.” She was the first woman ever to lead a Russian military unit. However, she had to go through wiring a petition to the Czar to enlist in the Imperial Russian army and endure harassment and ostracization. In the end, she became a decorated soldier.
Further, all-women units were created in 1917, like the 1st Petrograd Women’s Battalion, which was utilized to defend the Winter Palace. Bochkavera’s unit was also present in the October Revolution, fighting at the front.
As someone who’s seen what happens when the truth is distorted, I know how unfair it feels when those who’ve sacrificed the most lose their voice. At SOFREP, our veteran journalists, who once fought for freedom, now fight to bring you unfiltered, real-world intel. But without your support, we risk losing this vital source of truth. By subscribing, you’re not just leveling the playing field—you’re standing with those who’ve already given so much, ensuring they continue to serve by delivering stories that matter. Every subscription means we can hire more veterans and keep their hard-earned knowledge in the fight. Don’t let their voices be silenced. Please consider subscribing now.
One team, one fight,
Brandon Webb former Navy SEAL, Bestselling Author and Editor-in-Chief
Barrett is the world leader in long-range, large-caliber, precision rifle design and manufacturing. Barrett products are used by civilians, sport shooters, law enforcement agencies, the United States military, and more than 75 State Department-approved countries around the world.
PO Box 1077 MURFREESBORO, Tennessee 37133 United States
Scrubba Wash Bag
Our ultra-portable washing machine makes your journey easier. This convenient, pocket-sized travel companion allows you to travel lighter while helping you save money, time and water.
Our roots in shooting sports started off back in 1996 with our founder and CEO, Josh Ungier. His love of airguns took hold of our company from day one and we became the first e-commerce retailer dedicated to airguns, optics, ammo, and accessories. Over the next 25 years, customers turned to us for our unmatched product selection, great advice, education, and continued support of the sport and airgun industry.
COMMENTS
There are on this article.
You must become a subscriber or login to view or post comments on this article.